Y como dijo Sam Harris en uno de sus debates...(para no decepcionar a Jordan)
"I’m curious: How many ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ you consider yourselves to be devout Muslims? Let’s see a show ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ hands. Don’t mean to single anyone out, but not many. Now, you’re all aware, ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ course, that the Qur’an exists, and claims to be the perfect word ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ the creator ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ the universe?
You’re aware that once having heard this possibility and rejecting it, you’re all going to Hell, for eternity? I mean, needless to say, Dr. Craig and I are both going to Hell if this vision ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ life is true. The problem is that everything Dr. Craig has said tonight, with a few modifications, could be said in defense ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ Islam, in fact has been said in defense ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ Islam, ok.
The logic is exactly the same: We have a book that claims to be the word ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ the creator ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ the universe. It tells us about the nature ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ moral reality and how to live within it. But what if Muslims are right? What if Islam is true? How should we view God in moral terms? How would we view God in moral terms, or I should say, Allah? Ok, we have been born in the wrong place, to the wrong parents, given the wrong culture, given the wrong theology.
Ok, needless to say, Dr. Craig is doomed. He’s been thoroughly confused by Christianity. I mean, just appreciate what a bad position he’s now in to appreciate the true word ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ God. I have been thoroughly misled by science. Ok, where is Allah’s compassion? And yet, an eter—He’s omni—He’s omnipotent; he could change this in an instant. He could give us a sign that would convince everyone in this room. And yet he’s not gonna do it. And Hell awaits.
And Hell awaits our children, because we can’t help but mislead our children. Now, just hold this vision in mind, and first appreciate how little sleep you have lost over this possibility ok. Just feel in this moment how carefree you are, and will continue to be, in the face ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ this possibility. What are the chances that we’re all going to go Hell, for, for eternity, because we haven’t recognized the Qur’an to be the perfect word ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ the creator ************SPAM/BANNEAR************ the universe? Please know that this is exactly how Christianity appears to someone who’s not been indoctrinated by it."
No es un argumento por supuesto pero es una buena pregunta a la larga...e insatisfactoriamente contestada...